Re-employment: is that going to work?
Kelly v PGA European Tour
In the vast majority of cases an employee who succeeds in a claim for unfair dismissal will be awarded compensation up to certain limits. However, in some cases the Employment Tribunal may order that the employee be reinstated or re-engaged by the employer. The issue in the case of Kelly v PGA European Tour was whether it was appropriate to make such an order where it had been found that the dismissal was due to concerns regarding the employee’s capability to carry out their role.
Mr Kelly was dismissed after not agreeing to retire
Mr Kelly had been Group Marketing Director of the European Tour for a number of years when Mr Pelley was appointed as the new Chief Executive. Following a review of marketing Mr Pelley quickly formed the opinion that Mr Kelly didn’t have the analytical skills or marketing knowledge necessary to achieve the organisation’s aims for commercial growth. In subsequent meetings, which Mr Kelly secretly recorded, he suggested that he should retire but when terms were not agreed he dismissed Mr Kelly.
The Court of Appeal has held that whilst an Employment Tribunal was entitled to find that Mr Kelly’s dismissal was unfair it should not have made an order for re-engagement. The employer held genuine concerns relating to Mr Kelly’s ability to carry out the job and his secret recording of the conversations with Mr Pelley had impacted on trust and confidence. Given these findings and genuinely held concerns re-employment was not capable of being carried into effect with success.
Key takeaway points
Orders for reinstatement or re-engagement should only be made where it would be reasonably practicable for the employer to comply. This might explain why they are so rarely made in practice. Where the actions of the dismissed employee had damaged trust and confidence or where there were genuine and rational concerns about the employee’s ability to carry out their role an Employment Tribunal must take into account whether they could be successfully re-employed.
Do you require any more information regarding this case?
If you have any queries regarding this case, please get in touch with our expert listed below who will be happy to advise you and visit our employment page for information on all of the services we offer.
Gateley Plc is authorised and regulated by the SRA (Solicitors' Regulation Authority). Please visit the SRA website for details of the professional conduct rules which Gateley Legal must comply with.