Quick read

Why is independent legal advice necessary?

Gateley Legal

Article by

When a lender asks for a personal guarantee, it usually comes with the requirement that the proposed guarantor seeks independent legal advice.

We are often asked why and what type of legal advice should be given, read on to find out.

The simple answer – undue influence. 

When a person has given security for, or has guaranteed a loan to another, and was induced to do so by the ‘undue influence’ of the principal debtor, the security or guarantee may be unenforceable by the lender.

Following the judgment of the House of Lords in Etridge*, a lender is put on notice of undue influence if there is a non-commercial relationship between the parties. In these circumstances, most lenders will require the personal guarantor to seek independent legal advice to provide comfort to the lender that they have not been unduly influenced.

The requirement for independent legal advice also aims to ensure that:

  • the guarantor freely enters into the guarantee; an
  • the guarantor fully understands the consequences and risks associated with giving the guarantee.

What should the independent legal advice cover?

In Etridge, the House of Lords outlined the following ‘core minimum’ requirements for a solicitor when giving independent legal advice:

  1. the meeting between the solicitor and the guarantor must be face to face with no other party in attendance;
  2. the solicitor must use non-technical language when issuing their advice;
  3. the solicitor must explain to the guarantor why they have become involved in the transaction and that the lender will rely upon their involvement to counter any suggestion that there has been any undue influence;
  4. the solicitor must explain the nature of the guarantee and any accompanying transactional documents;
  5. the solicitor must explain the practical consequences of agreeing to give the guarantee and the risks associated with this, including the seriousness of those risks;
  6. the solicitor must make it clear that it is the guarantor’s decision whether to give the guarantee; and
  7. the solicitor must ensure that the guarantor is happy to proceed and for them to confirm in writing to the lender that the nature of the documents and associated risks have been explained to the guarantor and the guarantor agreed to give the guarantee.

Are different solicitors required to act for the guarantor?

While the House of Lords in Etridge considered that there were advantages in the guarantor being advised by a separate solicitor to the borrower, the potential cost implications may outweigh those advantages. In light of this, and the professional and legal duties owed by a solicitor to his or her client, the same solicitor may act for both the borrower and the guarantor, provided they are comfortable doing so.

*Royal Bank of Scotland v Etridge (No 2) and other appeals [2001] 3 FCR 481

Gateley Plc is authorised and regulated by the SRA (Solicitors' Regulation Authority). Please visit the SRA website for details of the professional conduct rules which Gateley Legal must comply with.